HIMYM QUIZ. Answer Save. This is my favorite “How I Met Your Mother” concept hands down. In the HIMYM pilot, as Ted recounts his first date with Robin to Marshall and Lily, Ted says that Robin falls under the olive theory. Carrot. By Jesse David Fox. As the series finale of How I Met Your Mother approaches, most viewers will say goodbye to Barney, Robin, and the rest of the MacLaren’s crew. 2 Answers. The Lobster Theory. The audience gets engrossed in the journey of Ted, Barney, Marshall, Lily & Robin in HIMYM and truly it’s one of the most loved shows EVER which is why we have a very special HIMYM quiz for you HIMYM … 8 years ago. Does anybody know? Olive Theory Pizzeria dishes out for a cause – Devils' Advocate The Olive Theory - How I Met Your Mother | Citazioni serie ... olive theory Tumblr posts - Tumbral.com In which episode of How I Met Your Mother is the olive theory explained? HIMYM & F.R.I.E.N.D.S are two of the most popular and loved TV sitcoms ever. How I Met Your Mother is a comedy about Ted and how he fell in love. The Pickle Theory . The Olive Theory is based on Lily and Marshall’s relationship. It’s a really sweet idea. You'll Never Get 100% On This How I Met Your Mother Quiz ... Marshall And Lily Argue That Based On What Theory Makes Them An Awesome Couple? The Olive Theory: Marshall and Lily claimed they were a perfect couple because of Marshall's hatred of olives and Lily's love of them, which creates a perfect balance. Occasionally, people ask me what I think the best sitcom pilot since 2000 is. From Ted and Robin’s meet-cute to Marshall and Lily’s flawed olive theory, the following is the perfect stroll down memory lane for a show that was awesome… at least 83 percent of the time. Looking Back at How I Met Your Mother’s Terrific Pilot. Relevance. Favorite Answer. The theory is that if one person likes olives and the other person in the relationship doesn’t, then they have perfect balance and are meant to be together. The title of the show is How I Met Your Mother, not “How I Met My Wife, Whom I Stayed With Forever.” Carter Bays and Craig Thomas, series creators, always … The Olive Theory. The Olive Theory This theory was mentioned in probably the first episode of How I Met Your Mother when Ted went on a date with Robin and she said that she hated olives and Ted got excited because he loves olives and Robin asked why and Ted then explains what the Olive Theory by saying this "Based on my friends Marshall and Lily.